Valentine's Day Cartoon - Cupid Fail

I asked my Facebook homies which version they liked better and the opinions seem to be pretty much split. I love the art part of cartooning, but the focus needs to be on the joke, so in this case, the second one will probably become my go-to version. Less distractions and a cleaner design. I still like the first one though and had a good time making it. Let me know what you think!